Monday, November 30, 2009

Pakistans Rapid Transformation-Khwaja

as i look back i see rapid transformations in pakistan.

30 years ago karachi was the most peaceful city in the world.today it is a dangerous place.

30 years ago even a 12 bore was regarded as a dangerous weapon.today lahore and all cities bristle with private owned automatics

30 years ago army was respected.today army officers are under attack in islamabad and even the army headquarters has been attacked.

as a retired government servant with a strong military background i feel that the fault is not in our stars but in ourselves.

zulfiqar ali bhutto introduced religion in pakistani politics by declaring ahmadis non muslims.

zia misused ideology .

musharraf had no ideology

benazir was clever but selfish

nawaz sharif is harmless but dumb

shahbaz sharif is fast but has ulterior motives

the problems of future need great leaders political and military and we have none.

Wednesday, November 25, 2009

AIR BASES 1971 WAR







IAF IN ITS PRELIMINARY YEARS

INTRODUCTION - THE IAF IN ITS PRELIMINARY YEARS

P.C LAL


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Indian Air Force (IAF) was officially born on 08 October 1932, when the Indian Air Force (IAF) act became effective. On that day six Indians were granted the King's commission on passing out as pilots and ground duty officers from RAF Cranwell. They had been sent earlier in 1930 and five of them became pilots while the sixth became a Ground Duty Officer. Among the five pilots were such well known names like Subroto Mukherjee, who became the first Indian Chief of Air Staff and Awan who had later opted for the Pakistan Air Force.

No.1 Squadron IAF, came into being on 1 April 1933 at Drigh Road, Karachi. There were five pilots commanded by an RAF officer and the first batch of Hawai Sepoys. The complement of the squadron consisted of four Westland Wapiti biplanes comprising 'A' Flight of the squadron. After 3 years of training, in which time more pilots joined the squadron. It was inducted into the North West Frontier Province (NWFP), which is now in Pakistan. The primary aim was to support the RAF and the Army in its operations against the frontier tribesmen.

Stationed at Miranshah, the pilots flew many sorties in their rickety aircraft, often suffering casualties in the form of forced landings or stopped engines due to the tribesmen firing. Throughout this period, with more pilots being trained at a rate of 5 to 6 per year, two more flights were raised and at the outbreak of the second world war, No.1 Squadron IAF was well experienced in its role of army cooperation, having received its baptism of fire at the frontier.

At the outbreak of the war, the IAF put into effect various expansion plans to raise more new squadrons. An RAF squadron at Risalpur was made responsible for training of aircrew and invitations were sent to commercial pilot license holders to join the newly created Indian Air Force Volunteer Reserve (IAFVR).

About a 100 such pilots joined the IAFVR and among them were men like P.C. Lal, Rajaram, etc. who rose to high posts after the war. All these pilots after a short conversion course were posted to newly raised coastal defence flights. They flew aircraft like the Wapiti, the Hart, Audax and some other types which have been requisitioned from civil owners. They flew long surveillance missions over the coastal waters and some times escorted ship convoys over sea lanes.

With the entry of Japan into the War, the expansion of the Indian Air Force was rapid. Flying schools were set up at Walton near Lahore and at Ambala. Two operational training units came up at Risalpur (for fighters) and Peshawar (for ground attack). The squadrons grew from one to ten.

A total of 3000 officers and 25,000 men were trained in the period 1942-45. Some 600 pilots flew with the ten squadrons, all of them seeing action against the Japanese in Burma. Some pilots attached to the RAF were sent to North Africa and England and saw action against the Germans and the Italians.

On the Burma front, the Indian AF flew in aircraft inferior to the Japanese. These aircraft, Hurricanes and Vengeances were those discarded by the RAF. Throughout the war, the IAF had to make do with aircraft discarded by the RAF as inferior and it was only at the end of the war did the IAF acquire the latest Marks Spitfires. In spite of this handicap it faired well in the war.

Field Marshal Slim in praising No.6 Dragons Squadron wrote, "I was impressed with the conduct of a reconnaissance squadron of the Indian Air Force. Flying in pairs the Indian pilots in their outmoded Hurricanes went out, time and again, in the face of overwhelming enemy fighter superiority...They were a happy, efficient, and a very gallant squadron." Coming from one of the greatest Generals of World War II it was proof indeed of the bravery of the pilots.

When the war ended Indian pilots had earned 1 DSO, 23 DFCs (including 1 bar) and a host of numerous other awards. In doing so it lost some 60 pilots killed in action. These figures would seem small compared to the RAF or the land armies but it should be remembered that the number that constituted the IAF was also small. The Indian Air Force's contribution to the victory of the commonwealth was recognised by King George VI who conferred the prefix "Royal" to the title making it the Royal Indian Air Force.

After the war ended, the IAF had ten fighter squadrons flying Hurricanes and Spitfire XIV's. It had sent one squadron (No.4) with the British Commonwealth Occupation Force in Japan. Some were at the frontier undergoing training and keeping guard. About the time it was thought necessary to raise a transport squadron.

Some individual pilots have had some experience on transport aircraft during the war but no special transport unit existed. So accordingly No.12 Squadron was raised with ten Dakotas in 1946. Even before training could commence a tropical storm came and wrote off all the aircraft. Despite this inauspicious start, No.12 began training on Oxfords, till replacement Dakotas began arriving.

More Spitfires and new Tempest II fighter bombers became available and the squadrons re-equipped with them, phasing out the Hurricanes. In the training role Harvards and Tigermoths were the mainstay for years to come. These were supplemented by the Percival Prentice and the Cornell trainers.

As partition became inevitable, so was the division of the Armed Forces. New India’s share of the Air Force amounted to seven fighter and one transport squadrons. Pakistan received two fighter and one newly raised transport squadron. The RIAF lost all of its permanent training establishments and major bases as they were all located in Pakistani territory. So all establishments had to be rebuilt from scratch.

The first Chief of Air Staff was Air Marshal Sir Thomas Elmhirst of the RAF. He was later succeeded by Air Marshal Sir Ivelew Chapman and later by Air Marshal Sir Eric Gibbs. All the three British service Officers served the Air Force well during their tenures as Air Chiefs. It was under their tenure that the expansion plan of the Air Force was drawn up and that the IAF fought in its first war.

Free India's Air Force had its first taste of action during the invasion of the Kashmir valley by the frontier tribesmen. These tribesmen, financially aided & armed by Pakistan and led by Army deserters, poured into Kashmir on 20 October 1947, and went into a frenzy killing, ransacking and pillaging through the Kashmiri villages. In reply to the Maharajah's plea for help and after his signing of the accession, India decided to send troops to Srinagar by air.

No.12 Squadron with its DC-3 Dakotas along with those of private airlines helped in the airlift. It was a remarkable achievement at such a short notice. Taking off from Palam the first Indian troops were landed at Srinagar airfield at 0930hrs on October 27th. At that time it wasn't even known whether the airfield has fallen to the tribesmen or not, but the risk was taken. On the first day the IAF and civilian Dakotas had airlifted the 1st battalion, The Sikh regiment and thus secured the safety of the airfield.

On October 28th, Tempests from Ambala attacked Enemy positions at Patan. Two days later the first Spitfires were flown to Srinagar, joining the Harvards which were already flown there. Fuel to keep these aircraft was hard to come by, but the Army developed ingenious methods to provide the necessary fuel. As soon as any Dakota landed, a jeep with a drum in its back would approach the aircraft, and with the pilots consent, the men would siphon off any extra amount of fuel that the captain of the aircraft would spare. The fuel thus collected kept the Spitfires flying later for the crucial battles of Badgam and Shalateng.

On November 3rd, the decisive battle of Badgam was fought in the vicinity of Srinagar airfield where the enemy launched a surprise attack. It was in this battle that Major Somnath Sharma was awarded the Param Vir Chakra (PVC) posthumously.

Two RIAF Spitfires came to the aid of the Indian Army by strafing the enemy attackers. The combined Army-Air Force onslaught beat back the attack. Four days later on November 7th, the battle of Shalateng took place which routed the enemy. The tribesmen kept retreating till Uri. Tempests of No.7 Sqn played an important part. according to Brigadier L.P. Sen, 400+ bodies were counted between Srinagar and Baramula, almost all due to air action.

Later on, Tempests provided much needed air support to the Army in the area of the Uri bowl where the fighting had stabilized. RIAF Tempests strafed and rocketed enemy concentrations at Kot, helped in the advance to Tithwal, dropped vital ammunition and food supplies to the beleaguered Skardu garrison. They destroyed enemy field guns at Poonch, and in a daring and spectacular low level air raid, destroyed the bridges over the Domel and Kishenganga rivers in the face of heavy ack-ack fire.

The lone transport Squadron was not left behind. No.12, in the course of its regular casualty evacuation and transport duties, airlifted 25 Pounder field guns to Poonch, flew the first troops to Leh, which was the first aircraft to land at Leh, and even bombing sorties in support of the army with the bombs being rolled out of the cargo bay by the aircrew.

The main driving force behind the squadron was Air Commodore Meher Singh, the head of the operational group in J&K. Meher Singh himself led many of the pioneering flights including the ones to Leh and Poonch. For leading and guiding the air operations in Jammu & Kashmir, he received the Maha Vir Chakra. Wing Commander K.L. Bhatia, CO No.12 Squadron, got the Vir Chakra as did many pilots of the squadron.

The fighting ended on 31 December 1948, the cease-fire bought about by UN Mediation. The IAF acquitted itself well earning four MVCs and 23 VrCs. Not much is known about its losses but at least one fighter, a Tempest was lost in the Tithwal area due to ack-ack fire. The pilot, Flying Officer U.G. Wright, baled out and had a harrowing experience during his parachute descent. He was fired at by rifles, LMG's and even 3" mortars! But he made it back to our lines.

One RIAF DC-3 went missing on the second day of the conflict, during the airlift and nothing was heard about the pilot, Ft. Lt. C.J. Mendoza and the 20 passengers till almost 40 years later, when the wreckage was stumbled upon and the remains of the crew members were laid to rest. No air-to-air encounters took place between the RPAF and the RIAF but on one occasion a lone RPAF Dakota was intercepted by two Tempests over Chilas.

Squadron Leader Masamalani and Flight Lieutenant Dogra were rocketing Chilas and stumbled onto the RPAF Dakota. However, inspite of radio warnings and firing across the path of the Dakota, the RPAF pilot slipped across the border. Later getting a "Sitara-E-Juraat" award for the escape.

Meanwhile down south, the Hyderabad police action was in progress. Here too the RIAF lent a hand to the Army. Tempests and Dakotas saw much action ,strafing, bombing and dropping leaflets against the Nizam's forces. However the scale of operations is minuscule compared to the Kashmir operations.

The end of the hostilities gave the RIAF some breathing space. It went ahead with its re-equipment plans and to build up as a 20 squadron force. About a 100 Spitfires and Tempests were acquired from Britain. To build up a bomber complement, the RIAF salvaged about 40 odd B-24 Liberator bombers from the ex-USAAF scrapyard at Kanpur and put these relics into the air. Initially, Lancaster bombers were offered by Britain, but it was decided to acquire more fighters with the same money and build up the required bomber force with the salvaged aircraft.

In November 1948, the RIAF became the first air arm in Asia to equip with Jet fighters. No.7 Sqn started inducting De Havilland Vampires bought from Britain and eventually some 400 were acquired. These vampires saw action even after 23 years in the 1971 war.

1950 saw India becoming a Republic. This led to all Royal titles being dropped and the RIAF was no exception. On 26 January 1950, she was just know as the Indian Air Force (IAF). Also, in order not to become dependent on only Great Britain for its arms purchases, the IAF started purchasing aircraft from other sources. In 1953 the Dassault Ouragan re-christened Toofani by the IAF was inducted. Belonging to the same generation as the Vampire, 104 of these straight winged fighters were received by the IAF.

On 1st April 1954, Air Marshal Subroto Mukherjee took over as the first Indian Chief of Air Staff. Mukherjee was the first Indian to command a squadron in the IAF and now he was the first Indian Air Chief. He had a good relationship with Nehru and this helped him to get the required allocation of finances for the air forces expansion plans.

During this period it can be certainly be said that the Air Force received privileged treatment more than the Army. When its Pakistani counterpart started inducting F-86 Sabres, efforts were made to acquire Hunter Mk.6 from the British. But the British did not release the Mk.6 for export and they offered only the Mk.4. So Mystere IV-A fighter-bombers were acquired from France. It was with the Mysteres that IAF pilots could break the sound barrier for the first time and later when the Hunter Mk.6 was cleared for export, the IAF acquired them too.

The offensive capability received a boost with Canberra bombers being purchased and Gnat fighters supplemented the interceptor force. Besides India, Finland was the only country to operate this diminutive fighter, while Britain operated Trainer versions.

The transport fleet was also increased to meet with the demands of India's great geographical size. Besides inducting more trustworthy Dakotas, Devons and Viscounts were bought in. One squadron of Ilyushin-14's were purchased. American Fairchild C-119 flying Packets joined the transport fleet. This aircraft could carry twice the cargo load that a Dakota could manage and thus were a welcome addition to the force.

The decision to manufacture the new Avro Hs.748 was taken and the agreement with Britain was signed in 1958. In 1960, No.44 Squadron was raised on Antonov-12s, which were the Russian equivalent of the American C-130 Hercules, which Pakistan had already got. In spite of all these additions, India's transport force was stretched to its limits by the increasing geographical and strategic demands.

The helicopter wing of the air force was born with some Bell 47 two seaters forming the initial equipment and soon some S-55 Whirlwinds joined the force. To cope with the High altitude operations the Russian Mi-4 was tested and found suitable and large numbers were inducted.

One thing is certain, the IAF was never starved out of money. Its expansion plans proceeded at an uninterrupted pace, without much canvassing on its part. What made the government favour the IAF over the Army? One theory is that the government was more keen on developing a "visible military force" as part of its political diplomacy, and the IAF fitted the part.

It was a lopsided policy, we had the best transport aircraft that money can buy but had no adequate parachutes to drop supplies at forward posts. The government would be most eager to buy shiny new fighters but be most miserly in purchasing spares for them.

Aircraft like the Spitfire and Tempest continued in service till 1956, the Dakota was in service till the 80s and the Liberator till 1967. It became difficult for the IAF to manage an effective air arm but it managed nevertheless, thanks to the men who led it.

Air Marshal Mukherjee died an untimely and tragic death in Japan while still in service and was succeeded by Air Marshal Aspy Merwan Engineer. Air Marshal Engineer, a DFC from Burma, was one of the famous Engineer brothers. It was in his tenure that the Indo-China conflict flared up. But before we go into this conflict, let us see how the IAF did in other short but limited encounters.

After more than twelve years, the Indian Air Force saw combat in a foreign land, fighting for a world cause. Six Canberras from No.5 Squadron were attached to the United Nations force in Congo. India also sent a brigade of troops there, and the Canberras were to support the operations of the UN there. The Canberras were under the command of Wg. Cdr. AIK Suares.

On 6 December 1961, after clashes broke out between UN forces and the Katangan rebels, The Canberras, operating from Leopoldville, attacked the Katangan airbase at Kolwazi. In the raid, they destroyed four Fouga Magister jets, the fuel dump and a bridge at Lufira. Besides they flew close support sorties for UN troops fighting on the ground, as well as escort missions for the USAF transport aircraft bringing in supplies. This was the first time that jet aircraft of the IAF went into action. The IAF acquitted itself well in this operation.

In the same month back in India, Operation Vijay, the plan to liberate Goa took place. There was no Portuguese air opposition and Canberras, Hunters, Ouragans and Vampires operated with impunity. Dabolim airport and the airstrip in Diu were put out of commission. Portuguese strong holds were attacked to smoothen up the Army's advance.

However, on one occasion, Vampires of No.45 Squadron operating from Belgaum were called up by the 2 Sikh LI to soften up Portuguese positions at Mapusa, and they ended up bombing positions of our own, 17th Para Fd Regt, injuring two. Throughout the action no Portuguese anti-aircraft fire was encountered and the whole operation can be termed as an exercise for the Indian Air Force to test itself.

The dawn of the new year bought forth new threats to the borders. A confrontation with China happened in October 1962. The Army had established posts in remote corners of Ladakh and NEFA. It became the IAF's responsibility to supply these posts from the air. The IAF had for some years did supply dropping in the jungles of Assam, and it continued doing so in Ladakh and NEFA.

Most of the time during the supply drops, the parachutes carrying the supplies would drift away into inaccessible valleys and gorges. A policy of reusing used parachutes recovered from these places saw supplies falling to the ground with unopened parachutes. In all the Army estimated that it recovered only 40% of the supplies airdropped by the Air Force, and it was barely sufficient to maintain its posts.

The Indo-China war started on 20th October 1962, with Chinese troops launching a heavy attack on Indian positions at the Tsangdhar area, in NEFA. On that day the IAF lost two Bell helicopters in quick succession to Chinese ground fire.

Before that, while the Indian troops were fighting for the posts, a lone Dakota came over lazily on its usual supply dropping run and the crew were shocked at being fired upon by the Chinese. This was the first indication that the IAF had of the war. No one had informed the Air Force authorities of the battle that had started three hours before.

Throughout the hostilities, IAF helicopters were primarily engaged in evacuating casualties. And after the Chinese ceasefire, in picking up numerous stragglers of the broken up 4th Infantry Division making there way back to the plains, most of these stragglers were forced to trek back across the country and suffered severe mental and physical strain on the way.

Scores of them were picked up by the helicopters including a Divisional commander himself. One Mi-4 helicopter was lost to ground fire in November 1962, another was abandoned at Zimithaung and it fell into Chinese hands intact. They later returned it after the ceasefire as a "gesture of goodwill."

On the Walong front, the IAF was the only means of supply and reinforcement to the Indian troops there. The only aircraft capable of operating from that airstrip was the Otter. These flew in supply and CASEVAC (Casualty Evacuation) missions till Walong fell.

One Otter which was made unserviceable by the Chinese shelling was abandoned. This was also later returned by the Chinese as a goodwill gesture. In most other wars, aircraft are deliberately destroyed to prevent their capture in the enemy hands. Sadly, no one found time to undertake such measures in the race to retreat.

While the situation in NEFA was bad, the IAF's performance in Aksai Chin in Ladakh was nothing short of excellent. The IAF's only AN-12 Squadron operated in this sector. They flew in reinforcements in the form of additional troops and AMX-13 tanks to everywhere, from Daulet Beg Oldi to Chushul. The PSP runway at Chushul almost disintegrated under the daily landings of these aircraft. At Leh, when after the cease-fire, a detachment of American C-130's landed there and the pilots were amazed at the tough and backward infrastructure facilities existing there. And with which the IAF was operating regularly.

Two questions remain in the readers minds about the 1962 conflict. Why was the Indian Air Force not used in an offensive role? And would it have made any difference if it had been used? It was thought at that time that the Chinese Air Force would retaliate if our air force was bought in.

The decision not to use the IAF was purely a political one, which unfairly displays a lack of trust in the ability of our own Air Force to defend our side. It was not known at that time that the Chinese Air Force was grounded due to shortage of fuel and if it had tried to bomb Indian cities, the IAF would certainly had the upper hand, as both our pilots and aircraft were much better than those of the Chinese.

The answer to the second question depends on a lot of factors. In Ladakh the Chinese attacked in masse, and in open areas and in broad daylight, employing field and rocket artillery. In the terrain, in which there was no vegetation, the IAF would have had a field day in attacking the ground targets. The Battles of Rezang La, Gurung Hill and Chushul would definitely have had different outcomes.

But we suffered our main reverses in NEFA where the Chinese employed no artillery, no road transport, where they had lots of forest cover to use for hiding, and most important of all, the Chinese there fought by outflanking moves, never using the road, but the numerous tracks in the jungles. Air power can only be used during the day, and the Chinese mounted night attacks at most of the places. They could afford to lie low during the day and move only in the nights. Thus nullifying most of the airpower advantage we had.

The IAF might have won a victory in the air but it would not have altered the situation in NEFA. Achieving air superiority would be meaningless if it was not exploited to wreck the enemies ground forces and more so if our own ground forces lack the ability to defend itself, which was what actually happened. Having the air situation in your favour does not alter the fact that your Generals are not up to the mark.

If it wasn't for the Chinese war we would have been caught off balance in 1965. And the consequences would have been more than the loss of barren uninhabited territory, and the 6000 men killed, missing or POW as in the Chinese invasion. The IAF came through the war with a bitter sense of disappointment.

It was not allowed to have a crack at the enemy, and its pride wasn't better from the fact that the Prime Minister Nehru had asked for protection for Indian cities from American planes while it was there to do the job. It would have been fair to say that it was not the defeat of the Armed Forces but the defeat of our politicians pet dreams.

After the war aid came from all over, Canada supplied Caribou STOL transports, France speeded up the supplies of Alloutte III helicopters, while the Americans loaned us the services of a C-130 Squadron and also supplied some old used Packets. A squadron of Otters was also procured from the Canadians.

The government entered into an agreement for the supply of MiG-21 fighters from the Soviet Union. Preparations were made to undertake production of the fighter. Old disused airfields in the North-East were reactivated, the result of which in the war nine years later, the IAF had no shortage of airfields to operate from.

To beef up the radar and communications network we got some old radar units from the United States, called the Air Defence Ground Environment System or ADGES. A plan was mutually agreed to set up a troop-scatter communication system. And one unit was being set up when the 1965 war started and further work was stopped.

To help the IAF assess its weaknesses and rectify them, an exercise was conducted jointly with the USAF and the RAF in 1963. For the first time, IAF Hunters operated alongside the Javelins of the RAF and the F-100 Super Sabres of the USAF. The Exercise aptly named Siksha was helpful for the IAF in gaining invaluable experience. Though the object was to learn to meet the Chinese threat, it helped in assessing the Pakistani threat too.

Perhaps the most important development was the approval of the government for the Indian Air Force to expand to a 45 Squadron force. The implementation of this plan would demand a tremendous effort from all those in the service.

On 1 August 1964, Air Marshal Arjan Singh D.F.C. took over as the Chief of Air Staff from Air Marshal Aspy Engineer. A tall and well built Sikh, he was a man of courage, no flamboyance, a rare combination of dignity, modesty, firmness and decision. He saw action in Burma, and was a distinguished pilot, and was the first Air Chief to be medically and operationally fit to fly all types of aircraft, including the latest type of jet fighters.

He had kept himself in flying trim by going to the squadrons and flying with them during their training. And as a flier to the end of his term he could have led a squadron into battle if the need ever rose. On Arjan Singh fell the responsibility to supervise the increase in the size of the Indian Air Force and train it in the shortest possible time.

Air Marshal Aspy Engineer was doing just that for an year and seven months and it was now Arjan Singh's job to complete what his predecessor had started, to forge the Indian Air Force into a formidable fighting machine. But he would never know that, because both he and his command would be put to test in less than an year.

Tuesday, November 24, 2009

Why not a civilian head of ISI?



Why not a civilian head of ISI?



November 17, 2009
By: Kamran Shafi
In view of the fact that the cardinal sin of the federal government to try and put the ISI under civilian control is cited as a reason behind all the obituaries presently being written about the imminent fall of a) just the president; b) all the major politicians; and c) the whole shoot, I’ve been trolling through the Internet to see how just many of the world’s top intelligence services are headed by serving military (in Pakistan’s case, read ‘army’) officers.
And how many are appointed by the army chief. Consider what I’ve come up with.
Except for two retired army officers in the early days, one a lieutenant colonel the other a major general, all the DGs of MI5, the “United Kingdom’s internal counter-intelligence and security agency were civil servants. The director-general reports to the home secretary, although the Security Service is not formally part of the home office”, and through him to the prime minister.“The Secret Intelligence Service (SIS), colloquially known as MI6 is the United Kingdom’s external intelligence agency. Under the direction of the Joint Intelligence Committee (JIC), it works alongside the Security Service (MI5), Government Communications Headquarters (GCHQ) and the defence intelligence staff (DIS).” Except for one naval captain, an admiral, a lieutenant colonel and a major general in the very early days, all of them retired, every single chief of this agency has been a ‘bloody civilian’, some from within its own ranks, others from the civil service. The present director is Britain’s former ambassador to the United Nations. The director reports to the chief cabinet secretary and through him to the prime minister.
Directors of Mossad, the dreaded Israeli intelligence agency which seems to be running rings (if reports in our conservative press and on our fire-breathing TV channels are to be believed) around our very own Mother of All Agencies, has been headed mostly by retired military officials (remember please that military service is compulsory in Israel) but also by ‘bloody civilians’. Mossad’s director is appointed by the prime minister and reports directly to him.
The director of the Central Intelligence Agency reports to the director of national intelligence (DNI), who in turn reports to the White House. The director is appointed by the president after recommendation from the DNI, and must be confirmed by a majority vote of the Senate. While there is no statutory provision which specifically excludes active military personnel from being nominated for the position, most directors have been civilians.
Barring Gen Reinhard Gehlen who set up the German intelligence agency Abteilung Fremde Heere Ost to principally keep an eye on the Russian easternfront during the Second World War, the present federal intelligence service, Bundesnachrichtendienst(BND), has always been headed by civilian public officials, notably by civil servant, lawyer and politician of the liberal Free Democratic Party, Klaus Kinkel who rose to be Germany’s federal minister of justice (1991–1992), foreign minister (1992–1998) and vice chancellor of Germany (1993–1998).
Next door in India all directors of RAW have been civilians, either civil servants or policemen or officials from within its own ranks. While the director RAW, also known as ‘Secretary (R)’, is under the direct command of the prime minister, he reports on an administrative basis to the cabinet secretary. However, on a daily basis ‘Secretary (R)’ reports to the national security adviser to the prime minister.
RAW too, if the press and TV channels are to be taken seriously, is running rings around us in close collaboration with Mossad.
So then, why is it that only in our country, our intelligence service is the fief of the army, and only of the army? Surely there are competent people other than generals who could well head the organisation and be a credit to it? I mean if all of the world’s leading agencies can be headed by civilians why not our ISI?
Meanwhile, back at the ranch, what is known as the ‘Ghairat Lobby’ has taken yet another drubbing with the most recent report of the LA Times to the effect that ever since 9/11 fully one-third of the CIA’s budget has been diverted to the ISI. It also reminds us brutally what the Commando has already told us in his ‘book’ (stand up, Humayun Gohar): that the ISI sold people, some surely terrorists some very surely innocent, to the Americans for cash payments as low as $5000 a go, and as high as millions of dollars for those who had huge head moneys on offer for their capture/death.
It also tells us that the CIA money was in addition to the $15bn that poured into the country during the Commando’s dictatorship. In the words of the LA Times the ISI, “had also collected tens of millions of dollars through a classified CIA programme that pays for the capture or killing of wanted militants, a clandestine counterpart to the rewards publicly offered by the State Department”. Will the Ghairat Lobby please sit up and take note, and understand that such reports make its ghairatmand stand on the Kerry-Lugar Law all the more ludicrous and hypocritical.
Let me here once more caution the leaders of the major political parties, the PML-N and the PPP: please close ranks and collectively beat back the ongoing assault on democracy by the establishment. Our country simply cannot take another extra-legal intervention (I did not say martial law) to remove any one individual, or two, from the scene. To President Zardari let me say, yet again: do not prevaricate, act now on the Charter of Democracy; break away from the too-clever-by-half -self-servers that you have surrounded yourself with.
To Mr Nawaz Sharif, this: Asif Zardari is not the only target of the establishment, he is only the first. You are next. Consider: if there is an anti-AZ story on one page, there is an anti-NS story on another page of the same newspaper on the same day. The Internet is full of planted stories on both the large political parties; stories that desperately try to turn lay people away from electoral politics. Be prepared for more dirt.
United you politicians will stand, divided you will fall.
P.S. The Balochistan High Court has ordered Musharraf to appear before it in the case of Nawab Akbar Bugti’s murder. How come there is no further reporting on this earth-shaking event, weeks down the line, as if it never happened?






Army knows how to protect National Interest
by
Maqbool Malik









KAMRA – Chief of the Army Staff General Ashfaq Parvez Kayani has made it clear that the United States will have to take Pakistan into confidence over new Afghan policy.The COAS said this while informally talking to a group of senior journalists shortly after the rollout ceremony of Pakistan’s first JF-17 aircraft here Monday. Gen Kayani said Americans knew that the Pakistan’s role was very much essential for stability in Afghanistan. “We know how to protect our national interests,” he added.When his attention was drawn towards US efforts to review its Afghan policy, General Kayani said the US would have to take Pakistan on board about its future Afghan policy. “The US leadership realises the importance of Pakistan and its key role in the war against terror. Therefore, it is out of question that US can sideline Pakistan on such an important issue”, General Kayani maintained. He defended the timing of operation Rah-e-Nijat launched to target the terror networks of late Baitullah Mehsud in South Waziristan Agency, saying security forces had the requisite element of surprise. “We launched the offensive and took the terrorists by surprise,” he added.General Kayani added that the operation was launched precisely one and a half hour after the high level briefing at the Prime Minister House, Islamabad on October 17.The COAS also dismissed the notion that hardcore TTP leaders and commanders had escaped to Afghanistan, adding that terrorists had failed to resist the operation and were on the run. “We are trying to hunt them in effort, and they are left with no space to regroup,” the COAS said.He explained that the security forces had made very important gains in Operation Rah-e-Nijat and vowed to hunt down the terrorists come what may.Besides securing key areas from terrorists and destruction of their bases, the security forces in South Waziristan have killed at least 550 terrorists and apprehended 15 others, whereas 60 security forces personnel have been martyred and 150 injured since the launch of Operation Rah-e-Nijat on October 17.

An Indian Colonel Analyses Pakistan GHQ Attack

Pakistan GHQ Attack: Some Key Questions

by Col. Rahul K. Bhonsle


The venomous terrorist attack on Islamabad’s Army Headquarters on 10th October has raised some key questions. What is the level of penetration of fundamentalists in the military, how effective are the controls over nuclear weapons, what is the morale of the army after the attack and how autonomous are Punjab based terrorist groups needs answers? The nature of the terrorist attack, the response of the security forces and subsequent reactions raise questions even on survivability of the Pakistani state with the only instrument capable of holding it together the Army seemingly in disarray. A survey of the attack would denote the reasons for this skepticism.
The Pakistan Army Headquarters, called as General Head Quarter or GHQ is in the garrison town of Rawalpindi near Mall Road. Rawalpindi garrison is hundred-year old and surrounded by civilian colonies thus it is not possible to close roads passing by the GHQ as per the Army public relations office. A new GHQ building was to come up, but this plan was shelved as the Army was facing resource crunch due to collapse of the Pakistan economy. The location was vulnerable and high security was essential.
The GHQ is heavily guarded with a infantry battalion nominated for the same including some of the key officers residential quarters. There are multiple barriers and vehicles are checked at each barrier. There is no clear run through given and vehicles have to zig zag through the barriers thereby preventing a vehicle borne suicide attack as it happened at the Marriot Hotel in Islamabad earlier.
The attack began shortly before noon on 10 October. The extremists arrived in a white car, opened fire near the GHQ and lobbed five hand grenades at the barrier to force their way into the headquarters. Security forces retaliated with gunfire and killed four terrorists, who were dressed in army uniforms. However simultaneously four to five attackers managed to infiltrate the heavily fortified compound using the diversion of the encounter. It is now known that the total number of attackers was ten. While four were killed in the initial others successfully intruded inside.
Initially it was felt by the security forces that all attackers had been killed in the first wave and there was no information of others having infiltrated and taken hostages. However soon there were sporadic firing from within the HQs it was clear that there were more attackers. This gap in reaction was exploited by the terrorists effectively.
The heavily armed attackers took up positions in the area, hurling grenades and firing sporadically at security forces. The personnel in the HQs and the guards were possibly confused by the attackers’ uniforms.
Having entered the compound the attackers held hostages including security men and civilian employees of the army headquarters. In one room, 22 hostages were clustered with three assailants, one of whom wore a suicide bomb jacket. There were 12 hostages in another room, where another assailant wore a suicide jacket.
Brig. Anwar ul-Haq, the director of security for military intelligence was shot in the first hour of the siege by one of the gunmen who had penetrated his building. When ul-Haq heard shooting, he interrupted a conference he was conducting and went into the corridor with an aide. When he saw a man in military uniform with his back turned to him, the brigadier told him to flee, but instead, the man turned around and shot the brigadier. Lt. Colonel Wasim was the other officer killed.
The Pakistani Army Special Services Group Commandoes launched rescue operation ‘Janbaz’. While negotiations were going on, some personnel were also send with food for the hostages, apparently these were allowed in and therefore could collect information. The commandos first killed the suicide bomber in one room, saving the situation from leading to any huge loss, but other militants in the room fired at two of the commandos, killing them. Then the commandoes attacked the other room to rescue the hostages. As commandos approached the second room, another suicide bomber blew himself up, bringing down the roof and causing injuries among the captives.
The terrorists were wearing suicide jackets and had explosives on them, but they could not detonate them as the commando action was underway. The army commandos caught the attackers injured team leader named Aqeel alias Dr. Usman who is said to be in a critical condition when reports last came in as he had attempted to kill himself but was possibly unable to and has been held for interrogation and extraction of information.
Three hostages were killed in the gun battle and all hostages were freed. Three commandoes also lost their lives. The death toll of security men came to 11. Three hostages were killed by the militants 10 militants were also killed and their leader Aqeel, alias Dr Usman arrested alive but was critically injured.
Reactions were forthcoming from across the globe, US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton has said the ghastly terror attack on the Pakistan Army General Headquarters (GHQ) in Rawalpindi has underlined the terror threat facing Pakistan. Clinton said she wants to point that the attack highlights the continuing threats to the Pakistani government and the ‘very important’ steps the civilian leadership, along with the military, are taking to root out the extremists and prevent violence and direct assaults on the sovereignty of the state. Similarly other heads of states including Indian Prime Minister and the Secretary General of the UN condemned the attack.
That there was a security failure should be apparent since the details about a forthcoming attack had been published on the front page of a national daily several days before it happened. The News International, a local English-language newspaper, had published the details of a report by the interior ministry that an attack on the General Headquarters (GHQ) was imminent. The 5 October report said that fighters from militant outfit Lashkar-e-Jhangvi - with the support of the Taliban in South Waziristan - were planning such an attack.
The use of security forces' uniforms by militants is a trend which is well established therefore the Army HQ troops should have been aware of the modus operandi but did not react effectively. The attackers were trained in Waziristan in complex terrorist attacks and included mounting both suicide attacks and sophisticated “fidayeen” assaults. The difference in this attack is also that where previously the militants originated from the tribal areas, now there is an increasing representation from the Punjab and other parts of the country. Southern Punjab is emerging as the hot bed of militancy and people and leaders from the North West Frontier Province are claiming that the government should also launch operations in Southern Punjab, thus indicating possible emergence of a regional divide in the country, which could be dangerous.
Well-informed sources in Pakistan say that the intelligence establishment has failed to identify and weed out the pro-jihadi elements in the Armed Forces and the intelligence establishment
This attack has been followed by a series of attacks in the country over the week leading to a large number of casualties of innocent people mostly common citizens and also police and intelligence personnel. This have shaken up the security establishment.
The other issue is the nuclear weapons. How far are these considered secure given that there could be some penetration of the inner or outer ring by fundamentalist elements in the Army will remain a moot question. The Pakistani establishment needs to provide immediate answers to reassure the World.
There is therefore an urgent need for a security blanket over the most vulnerable areas which should be made virtually impenetrable. In the long run identifying and weeding out fundamentalist elements in the security forces is also essential. Is the Pakistani Army up to the challenge and will it do so immediately needs elaboration?
October 18, 2009

The Evolution of The Pakistan Army

The Evolution of The Pakistan Army

By Brig. (Ret.) Noor A. Husain

The story of the evolution of the Pakistan Army is the story of the
birth of Pakistan itself against heavy odds. It is a story of
unflinching determination of the Founding Fathers led by the
Quaid-e-Azam Muhammad Ali Jinnah, and of officers and men to create a
nation and its armed forces.

On 3 June 1947, the British Government announced the plan for the
partition of the sub-continent between India and Pakistan, and for the
transfer of power to the two new states on 15 August 1947. On 30 June
1947, the procedure for the division of the armed forces was agreed
upon by the Partition Council, chaired by the Viceroy of India Lord
Mountbatten and consisting of the top leaders of the Muslim League and
the Indian Congress. Field Marshal Auchinleck, then C-in-C India, was
appointed Supreme Commander under Mountbatten to ensure smooth
division of units, stores and so on. It was announced on 1 July 1947,
that both countries would have operational control of their respective
armed forces by 15 August 1947.


The Early Years
Under the Partition Council a Joint Defence Council was formed with
Viceroy Mountbatten as chairman, under which was an Armed Forces
Reconstitution Committee under FM Auchinleck, consisting of
representatives of the future Indian and Pakistani armies. Between
1939-195, the strength of the Indian Army grew to a maximum of
2,018,196 personnel. On the eve of Partition in 1947, the figure had
come down to about 11,800 officers, 450,000 other ranks plus about
50,000 of Indian Princely State Forces. It is noteworthy that at that
time (as per policy of the British Raj since 1857) there were only two
completely Muslim combat units (1/15 Punjab Regiment and 3/16 Punjab
Regiment), although there were several completely Hindu and Sikh units
and regiments of the combat arms. The original agreement called for
the armed forces and other assets to be divided to the ration of 64%
for India and 36% for Pakistan, but Pakistan was later forced to
accept an 1/3 share of assets. Of the total 46 training
establishments; only nine were located in Pakistan; all of the 17
Ordnance Depots were located in India, as were most of the Ordnance
Depots and Engineer Store Depots. In addition to Pakistan receiving
far less stores than originally stipulated, most of the stores
received were of general nature, perishable, unwanted and obsolete.

The move of 150,000 Pakistani personnel as well 508 units and sub
units of various sizes was to be carried out by rail through Indian
Punjab and Sikh Princely States. After 53 trains carrying personnel
and their families were attacked, detailed and massacred by armed
bands of Sikhs and Hindus in connivance with the railway authorities,
the sea route from Bombay to Karachi was adopted. The Punjab Boundary
Force consisting of five brigades under MajGen Rees was created by FM
Auchinleck's Supreme HQ in August 1947 to escort refugees from border
districts of the two Punjabs across the international borders. Its
area of responsibility covered 37,500 square miles and a population of
14,5 million. It was a gigantic task for a limited force manned
largely by neutral British officers. About seven million Muslims
migrated to Pakistan, and five million Sikhs and Hindus to India; a
million perished.

Against an estimated requirement for about 4,000 officers, Pakistan
had initially only about 2,300 - the gap being filled up on
Quaid-e-Azam's appeal, to some extent, by 484 experienced and
qualified British officers, who volunteered to stay and help Pakistan
and the Pakistan Army in difficult times. Many Polish and Hungarian
officers also volunteered for the medical corps. Prior to August 1947,
the most senior Pakistani (and Indian) officers were in ranks of
brigadiers; after independence, the command of Army units had to be
given to officers in their early 30s with eighteen years service, many
of whom had combat experience and had won battlefield awards in Word
War II. Similarly, brigade commanders had 13-15 years service and
division commanders 19-20 years. Out of the Northern Command HQ
nucleus, the GHQ was organised at its present location. LtGen
Messervy, the then GOC-in-C Northern Command, was promoted and
appointed Commander-in-Chief (C-in-C) Pakistan Army. The GHQ started
functioning on 15 August 1947 without adequate staff or records, these
held back in New Delhi.

By August 1947, the 7th Division (located in Rawalpindi with two
brigades) was the Pakistan Army's only division. There also were
static HQ designated "Areas" and "Sub-areas", having brigades and
battalions at more than 50% below strength. In the following months,
as Pakistani personnel kept arriving from all over India, Middle East
and South East Asia by rail and sea, the 8th Division was organised
out of the Sind-Balochistan Area, and the 9th (F) Division was created
out of brigades of the Peshawar and Wazirstan Areas. Similarly, the
Lahore Area was re-organised as 10th Division, and the 12th Division
was raised in November 1948. The forces in East Pakistan (now
Bangladesh) were designated as East Pakistan Army, then a Sub-area and
finally in December 1948 as HQ 14th Division, initially with only two
battalions that eventually were built up to brigade strength. By
October 1947, guarding 5,000 miles of West and East Pakistan's
frontiers were about ten infantry brigades at less then 50% strength,
and an armoured brigade with only 13 running STUART tanks. The Army
has ammunition reserves for less than one week. In a Joint Defence
Council Meeting, both Mountbatten and Supreme Commander Auchinleck had
made it clear to Pakistan that in case of war with India, no other
member of the Commonwealth would come to Pakistan's help. Field
Marshal Ayub Khan, the first Pakistani C-in-C, was to recall in later
years: "It would always be a matter of pride and glory for this army
when history will recall how heavy a burden was placed on its young
shoulders and how creditably it always rose to the occasion".

After the fraudulent accession of Kashmir by the Maharaja on 27
October, Mountbatten and Nehru air-launched the Indian Army into the
Srinagar Valley. The India Army's offensive was halted at the
Ceasefire Line (now Line of Control) initially by Azad Kashmir Forces,
and from April 1948 with support of the ill-organised Pakistan Army
without adequate logistic support. At midnight on 30 December, GHQ
India asked for a ceasefire to become effective on 1 January 1949.
Pakistan accepted, as the fate of Jammu and Kashmir had been taken
over by the UNO. Thus ended the six-month war in Kashmir. By the end
of 1948 five infantry divisions had been organised, but these were
still lacking their full complement of supporting arms and services.
The few artillery regiments received at partition were grouped into
three Artillery Groups under independent headquarters to ensure
maximum flexibility. By early 1949, the Pakistan Army had completed
its formative stage and had been bloodied in battle experience, and
continued its re-organisation. On integration of Bahawalpur State in
January 1949, the 6th (B) Division was created, but this was disbanded
in 1956 on the re-organisation of the army.


Evolution And Conflicts
Back in August 1947, Quaid-e-Azam Muhammad Ali Jinnah, foreseeing the
financial and military difficulties ahead, asked for US economic and
military aid. Incidentally, the same request had also been submitted
by New Delhi and Kabul. After an evaluation of Pakistan's strategic
location at the crossroads of South-, Central-and West Asia in
proximity to both China and the Soviet Union, the USA acceded to
Pakistan's request under the American Mutual Security Legislation. In
early 1954, Pakistan and the USA signed a Mutual Defence Assistance
Agreement.

Between 1954-1965, Pakistan received US$650 million in military
grants, US$619 million in defence support assistance, and US$55
million in cash or commercial purchases. This aid enhanced Pakistani
defence capability by increasing the firepower and mobility, and
improving C3I facilities of five and a half divisions. The armed
forces were modernised in keeping with the world trends; two Corps HQ
were also catered for. Many senior and junior officers went for
training and orientation to USA; new cantonments were built, and
existing ones were expanded and modernised.

The Ran of Kutch Conflict (April 1965)

India and Pakistan became engaged in a short but sharp conflict into
Pakistani claimed-area in the Ran of Kutch in April 1965. Both armies
had fully mobilised. Pakistan eventually proposed a ceasefire, which
India accepted; an agreement was signed, and the forces disengaged.
The Award by the Arbitration Tribunal vindicated Pakistan's position.
India then shifted the centre of gravity of operations to the Northern
Areas.

The Kashmir War (September 1965)

After several ceasefire violations, India attacked across the
international border from Sialkot to Sind sectors. The attacks were
halted on all fronts, and in a series of counter-attacks the Pakistan
Army penetrated six-eight miles inside Indian territory capturing more
territory than the Indian Army. The biggest tank battle since World
War II was fought at Chawinda, inflicting heavy casualties. India
eventually asked for a ceasefire, arranged by the UN on 23 September
1965.

The Third Evolution Phase (1966 - 1970)

In 1966, commenced the third phase of the evolution of the Pakistan
Army, which was able to at least partially enhance its defence
capability over these five years. The US embargo on military aid to
Pakistan, and the continued Soviet heavy build-up of Indian forces,
forced Pakistan to turn China, North Korea, Germany, Italy and France
for its defence procurement programmes. China, a time-tested friend
and neighbour, enabled Pakistan to raise three fully equipped infantry
divisions with gun and vehicles, 900 Chinese tanks, and MiG-19F
aircraft for the air force. France supplied MIRAGE aircraft and
submarines. In 1968, the Soviet Union offered US$30 million worth of
aid to Pakistan and supplied 100 T-55 tanks, Mi-8 helicopters, guns
and vehicles; in 1969, however, Soviet support was abruptly stopped
under Indian pressure.

The 1971 War

1971 was the most tragic year in Pakistan's history, a year of
political crises and conflict. Unable to resolve a political problem
by political means, the then Martial Law regime resorted to Military
action in East Pakistan on the night on 25/26 March. Widespread
insurgency broke out, covertly aided by Indian trained infiltrators
and India's Border Security Forces. In the first week of April,
personnel of two infantry divisions and civil armed forces were
airlifted in Pakistan International Airlines (PIA) planes with a
6,000-mile non-stop route via Sri Lanka - the longest operational air
move by the army. Quick reaction by the Pakistani authorities restored
80% normalcy in the eastern wing of the country. Covert operations
having failed, India concentrated about 400,000 regular army personnel
in 12 divisions supported by five tank regiments, seven air force
squadrons and Indian Navy. These forces, further strengthened by about
100,000 guerrilla (Mukti Bahini) attacked from all directions on 20
fronts across the international border on 21 November, without a
formal declaration of war. Intense fighting raged till 16 December in
both Pakistan's wings; no town or battalion position could be overrun,
till a ceasefire accepted by Pakistan was perfidiously changed into
surrender by Indian-Soviet machinations.

1979 To Present

In December 1979, the Soviet Union invaded Afghanistan. The US offered
US$400 million worth of military aid, which was however spurned by
Pakistan as inadequate for a "frontline state". Apprehensive of the
two front threats to Pakistan, in 1981 the US again offered a package
of US$1.5 billion worth of military aid. This was accepted and in five
years provided 40 F-16 fighters, 100 M-48 tanks, 64 M-109 155mm SP
howitzers, 40 M-110 203mm SP howitzers, 75 towed howitzers, and 1,005
TOW anti-tank missile system, considerably enhancing Pakistan's
defence capability. In 1984, Indian forces, violating the 1949
Ceasefire Agreement and the 1972 Simla Accord, launched a military
aggression into the Siachen Glacier. Pakistan's fast counter-move
against their aggression blocked a threat from developing to
Pakistan's strategically vital Northern Areas and the Karakoram
Highway. India and Pakistan are now engaged into a military conflict
on the world's highest battlefield.

By 1989, the Soviet Union - having suffered heavy losses in men and
material, and unable to withstand the Jehad - commenced withdrawing
its forces from Afghanistan. Under the Pressler Amendment, the US
again imposed an embargo on all economical and military aid to
Pakistan, which continued for five years. In 1995, the Brown Amendment
authorised a one-time delivery of US military equipment, contracted
for prior to October 1990, worth US$368 million. However, the
additional 28 F-16 aircraft costing US$658 million and already paid
for by Pakistan were not delivered.


Concluding Remarks
The Pakistan Army, like Pakistan, started virtually from a scratch on
14 August 1947, in the face of heavy odds. During these 50 years, the
army, like the navy and air force, has evolved into a highly motivated
and modern force defending the ideological and geographical frontiers
of Pakistan. Today, almost 66 infantry brigades, 15 armoured brigades,
30 artillery brigades, eight air defence brigades, 17 army aviation
squadrons, all equipped with state-of-the-art weapon systems,
organised under about 19 division HQs and 9 Corps HQs, stand alert and
ready as to Warden of the Marches.

ISI Chief confronts CIA counterpart with evidence

ISI Chief confronts CIA counterpart with evidence
By: Maqbool Malik | Published: November 21, 2009


ISLAMABAD – Serious differences are understood to have cropped up between Pakistan’s premier intelligence agency ISI and US Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) over the latter’s dismal role in countering terrorism in Pakistan, TheNation reliably learnt on Friday.
According to well-placed sources, the differences between the two strategic partners in war against terror cropped up when ISI Chief Lt. General Ahmed Shujja Pasha in a meeting expressed his disappointment to his US counterpart, the CIA chief spymaster Leon Panetta, over the US failure to help Pakistan in counter-terrorism efforts.
Although there was no official confirmation either from the US Embassy or ISPR about the meeting, it was learnt that both of them had thought provoking talks here in which General Pasha had presented to the CIA official a shocking evidence about Indian interference into Pakistan by using Afghanistan soil. General Pasha, the informed sources said, had presented the evidence about Indian efforts aiding terrorism in Balochistan and Waziristan.
The sources said that General Pasha was critical to the CIA’s counter-terrorism strategy in Afghanistan and CIA’s failure to provide concrete actionable information to Pakistan in containing flow of aid to terror networks operating from Afghanistan to destabilize Pakistan.
The sources said that the CIA chief is currently visiting Pakistan as a follow-up to the visit of US of Secretary of State Hillary Clinton to address complains of Pakistan’s military establishment.
The CIA chief is to meet Army Chief General Ashfaq Pavez Kayani today and is likely to get the similar input from him, the sources said. He is also expected to visit Saudi Arabia before his return to USA.